First, let’s start with the price. The Physicians Formula eyeliner is about $11-15 and the Starlooks is about $19. Therefore, physicians formula is cheaper. Also physicians formula is easier to find, and it’s in almost every drugstore. Starlooks can be found on their website and very few sites. Physicians Formula has a smaller tip than the Starlooks one.
I got both of these eyeliners around the same time. The Starlooks one dried out on me. I couldn’t believe it only used it a few times and it dried up. The Starlooks one fades away after a few hours and is not as dark. I like the way the Physicians Formula product looks it’s very futuristic and beautiful.
The only con I can see that’s not really a con for me is that Physicians Formula eyeliner takes a long time to fill in. Although this eyeliner pen wasn’t great I still think this is a great company but this $19 eyeliner pen was a miss for me. I think Physicians Formula wins in this comparison.
Let me know if you agree, or if things were different for you maybe I got a dud.
XOXO AIDENSWORLD21 ♡